Duff and Carter also broke up for good a few months later when Carter cheated on her with someone else (OMG! The girls silently battled on the red carpet, showing up to each other's premieres. It made us both look bad and put up a big weirdness." Tina Fey backed up those claims, recently confessing that Duff was a (confusing) topic of discussion on the Mean Girls set.
But Lohan took the fight to the next level when she allegedly called Duff's A Cinderella Story co-star Chad Michael Murray to spread lies about her. Just when it seemed like it had all died down, this happened.
"He does, I keep seeing that, that he keeps doing that. I mean, that was so long ago, and obviously I'm still married, and I have a baby and we kind of just…"However, Duff and Comrie haven't made a clean split.
In March, they were seen having breakfast together in Beverly Hills with their son.
There was no shortage of fantastic drama over Carter's back-and-forth with the stars in the early '00s and Twitter wasn't even around yet to stir the pot. Even Aaron Carter misses Aaron Carter and Hilary Duff.
It was a different time then — Lohan hadn't been to rehab, Duff was Lizzie Mc Guire, and Carter was, well, relevant. Let's revisit the turn of the millennium: Background: Back in 2000, Carter was the cute younger brother of Backstreet Boys heartthrob Nick Carter who had his own hit (to put it very kindly): "That's How I Beat Shaq." Surely you remember this video.
However, the multi-platinum pop sensation's wandering eye got the best of him and he ended up cheating on Duff with her best friend. While we all remember Lindsay now for her cutesy little drug-alcohol-exhaustion antics, there was a time when we knew her for this love affair. While people may scoff at this juvenile drama, I feel completely comfortable saying that this was the “who shot J. It's practically the precursor to the Jennifer Aniston/Brad Pitt/Angelina Jolie love triangle.